Poseidon Score

Every fly rod we've tested, ranked

We cast every rod we review and score it on eight categories, 10 points each, for a Poseidon Score out of 80. Filter the tables, sort any column, and tick up to four rods to compare them side by side. Click a rod for the full written review.

Tick up to 4 rods to compare them side by side.

4-weight fly rods

3 rods tested · ranked by total
Compare # Rod Water PriceAccur.Dist.SwingComp.GripLooksValueCoolTotal Shop
1 Thomas & Thomas Paradigm8'4" · 4wt Freshwater $1,045.00857999.57761.5/80 Shop
2 Epic Fast Glass7'6" · 4wt Freshwater $799.99736891071060/80 Shop
3 TFO Finesse Trout8'9" · 4wt · Discontinued Freshwater $229.956547758648/80

5-weight fly rods

40 rods tested · ranked by total
Compare # Rod Water PriceAccur.Dist.SwingComp.GripLooksValueCoolTotal Shop
1 Atlas Signature Freshwater9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $499.999.599.510108109.575.4/80 Shop
2 Scott Centric9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $995.009.59.5898981071/80 Shop
3 Thomas & Thomas Avantt 29'0" · 5wt Freshwater $1,045.0097.599.5101087.570.5/80 Shop
4 Hardy Ultralight10'0" · 5wt · Discontinued Freshwater $895.009.51099.58897.570.5/80
5 Orvis Helios 4D9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $1,098.00108.58.599871070/80 Shop
6 Sage R89'0" · 5wt Freshwater $1,100.0098.59710971069.5/80 Shop
7 Winston Pure 29'0" · 5wt Freshwater $995.008.579.59101087.569.5/80 Shop
8 Scott GT 8'10" · 5wt Freshwater $1,095.008.56.599.59.59.57.5969/80 Shop
9 G. Loomis NRX+ Freshwater9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $960.009106.59888.59.568.5/80 Shop
10 Orvis Helios 4F9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $1,098.008.588.599871068/80 Shop
11 Sage Power R8 9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $1,100.0091067108.57866.5/80 Shop
12 Epic Carbon9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $799.999.571097106866.5/80 Shop
13 G. Loomis NRX+ LP9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $960.008.57.59888.58966.5/80 Shop
14 Douglas Sky G9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $929.009.58108778966.5/80 Shop
15 Sage Arrow 9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $725.0098771098.5866.5/80 Shop
16 TFO Solution9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $549.9589.5788.589866/80 Shop
17 St. Croix Evos 9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $975.008.58.569998.57.566/80 Shop
18 Winston Air 29'0" · 5wt Freshwater $1,195.0086.57.59.59.51068.565.5/80 Shop
19 Scott Session9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $695.007.578.58.5109.57765/80 Shop
20 Lamson Liquid Outfit9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $399.998.597.57.587.59.5764.5/80 Shop
21 Orvis Recon 39'0" · 5wt Both $698.008778.59.58.58864.5/80 Shop
22 Hardy Marksman9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $995.009.57108777.5864/80 Shop
23 Hardy Ultralight x9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $799.999989.57.577764/80 Shop
24 Douglas DXF Gen 29'0" · 5wt Freshwater $549.008.5787.5888.5863.5/80 Shop
25 Lamson Radius9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $499.999.56.5978.5710663.5/80 Shop
26 Greys GR80 Streamflex9'0" · 5wt · Discontinued Freshwater $375.0099778710663/80
27 St. Croix Technica 9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $975.008.576.599.587.5763/80 Shop
28 Loop 7X9'0" · 5wt · Discontinued Freshwater $950.009.57810667962.5/80
29 Lamson Guru9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $299.998887.577.59762/80 Shop
30 Hardy Aydon9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $525.0086.5777.588.5759.5/80 Shop
31 Greys GR609'0" · 5wt · Discontinued Freshwater $225.95878.56.5879559/80
32 TFO Pro III9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $229.95774.578897.558/80 Shop
33 Greys Lance9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $209.9597.57676.510457/80 Shop
34 Orvis Recon 2 Freshwater9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $598.007.5758786856.5/80 Shop
35 Redington Wrangler 9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $199.997757.5777754.5/80 Shop
36 Fenwick Fenlite Streamflex9'0" · 5wt · Discontinued Freshwater $349.9588.567866453.5/80
37 Redington EDC 9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $379.998756758753/80 Shop
38 Greys Wing9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $354.99887776.55452.5/80 Shop
39 Sage Trout LL9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $925.0078751076751/80 Shop
40 Redington Trace9'0" · 5wt Freshwater $244.9975765776.550.5/80 Shop

8-weight fly rods

21 rods tested · ranked by total
Compare # Rod Water PriceAccur.Dist.SwingComp.GripLooksValueCoolTotal Shop
1 Atlas Signature Saltwater 9'0" · 8wt Saltwater $499.999109.51099107.574/80 Shop
2 Winston Air 2 Max8'6" · 8wt Freshwater $1,295.008.59.510109.59.57872/80 Shop
3 Scott Sector9'0" · 8wt Saltwater $875.99989109971071/80 Shop
4 G. Loomis NRX+ Saltwater9'0" · 8wt Saltwater $1,040.0098.59.598.58.589.570.5/80 Shop
5 Hardy Marksman Z9'0" · 8wt Saltwater $1,050.009109.59.5788.5970.5/80 Shop
6 Scott Meridian9'0" · 8wt · Discontinued Saltwater $865.009999998769/80
7 Scott Wave9'0" · 8wt Saltwater $695.007.59889.59.58.58.568.5/80 Shop
8 Thomas & Thomas Sextant9'0" · 8wt Saltwater $1,095.0098.569.58.5107.5968/80 Shop
9 G. Loomis Asquith II 9'0" · 8wt Saltwater $1,570.00999988.56967.5/80 Shop
10 Sage Salt R89'0" · 8wt Saltwater $1,150.008.57.5771098966/80 Shop
11 Hardy Zane Pro9'0" · 8wt · Discontinued Saltwater $950.00977.59.5987.57.565/80
12 Winston Winston Alpha +9'0" · 8wt · Discontinued Saltwater $955.008.598899.56664/80
13 Sage Maverick9'0" · 8wt Saltwater $675.0089877797.562.5/80 Shop
14 Sage Payload9'0" · 8wt Saltwater $750.0069.5761079761.5/80 Shop
15 TFO Blitz9'0" · 8wt Saltwater $499.9577.59.57.57697.561/80 Shop
16 TFO Axiom II X9'0" · 8wt · Discontinued Saltwater $449.958678869759/80
17 TFO Axiom II9'0" · 8wt · Discontinued Saltwater $284.958697859759/80
18 TFO Moment9'0" · 8wt Saltwater $649.957.485887.56858/80 Shop
19 TFO Mangrove Coast9'0" · 8wt Saltwater $399.95766.56.587.59.56.557.5/80 Shop
20 Orvis Recon 2 Saltwater9'0" · 8wt Saltwater $598.008557887.5856.5/80 Shop
21 Fenwick Fenlite Saltwater9'0" · 8wt · Discontinued Saltwater $349.9587477.566348.5/80

The best fly rods we've tested, by line weight

4-weight

We have cast and scored 3 4-weight fly rods. The highest Poseidon Score goes to the Thomas & Thomas Paradigm at 61.5 out of 80, followed by the Epic Fast Glass (60) and the TFO Finesse Trout (48). For value, the TFO Finesse Trout scored highest at 8 out of 10. The least expensive 4-weight on the list that is still in production is the Epic Fast Glass at $799.99.

5-weight

We have cast and scored 40 5-weight fly rods. The highest Poseidon Score goes to the Atlas Signature Freshwater at 75.4 out of 80, followed by the Scott Centric (71) and the Thomas & Thomas Avantt 2 (70.5). For value, the Atlas Signature Freshwater scored highest at 10 out of 10. The least expensive 5-weight on the list that is still in production is the Redington Wrangler at $199.99.

8-weight

We have cast and scored 21 8-weight fly rods. The highest Poseidon Score goes to the Atlas Signature Saltwater at 74 out of 80, followed by the Winston Air 2 Max (72) and the Scott Sector (71). For value, the Atlas Signature Saltwater scored highest at 10 out of 10. The least expensive 8-weight on the list that is still in production is the TFO Mangrove Coast at $399.95.

How the Poseidon Score works

Every rod on this page went through the same test: we cast it, fished it and scored it on eight categories, 10 points each, for a Poseidon Score out of 80. The same crew scores every rod, so a 9 on one rod means the same as a 9 on another.

  • Accuracy. How reliably the rod puts the fly where you are looking, close in and at range.
  • Distance. How much line the rod carries and how easily it reaches the far bank or the next flat.
  • Swing weight. How light and lively the rod feels in hand through a day of casting, not just on the scale.
  • Components. Guides, reel seat, wraps and finish: the hardware you live with for years.
  • Grip. Cork quality and handle shape, and how the rod sits in your hand.
  • Looks. Blank finish, colour and the small touches that make a rod feel special.
  • Value. What you get for the price next to everything else in its class.
  • Cool factor. The part that is hard to measure: does the rod make you want to go fishing?

Scores are our opinion from real casting, not a lab figure. A rod that scores 60 is still a very good fly rod; the gap between 70 and 75 is the difference between excellent and the best we have cast.

Poseidon Score questions

What is a Poseidon Score?
Our rating for fly rods: eight categories, 10 points each, 80 in total. Every rod we review on YouTube gets one, and the score on a review page is the same number you see here.

Who does the testing?
The Trident Fly Fishing crew. We sell these rods, and we fish them. That is why every rod in the same line weight is cast with the same lines and scored by the same people.

Does the highest score mean the best rod for me?
Not always. A rod that wins on distance can lose on close-in accuracy, and swing weight matters more on a long day than it does in a five-minute test cast. Tick up to four rods above and compare the categories that matter to how you fish.

Why do some rods show an MSRP instead of a price?
Those rods are discontinued or temporarily unavailable. We keep their scores so you can compare a used or closeout rod against what is current.

How often is this page updated?
Scores land here as soon as a new review is published. Prices are today's store prices.

Scores are updated as we test new rods. Prices are today's store prices; discontinued rods show their last MSRP.