Trident Travel is your complete fly fishing travel service. We offer incredible fly fishing destinations around the globe, with new locations being added frequently. With Trident, you'll get our low-price guarantee, and you'll never pay any credit card or booking fees. For a limited time, you'll even earn reward points on every trip you book! If you find this review informative, please consider booking your next fly fishing trip through Trident Travel to support our reviews.
The Salmon River in Pulaski, New York, is one of the most well-known steelhead rivers in the Northeast. Its cold autumn flows, deep holding pools, and steady runs provide reliable opportunities for anglers from October through spring. The town of Pulaski revolves around the river, with diners, motels, fly shops, and guide services that cater to those who make the annual pilgrimage in search of chrome. We recently returned from a short trip to scratch the seasonal itch of pursuing fresh steelhead, and as always, the river offered a blend of challenge, reward, and quiet moments that make this fishery special.
Travel To Pulaski
Getting to Pulaski, New York, is relatively straightforward for anglers traveling from New England, the Mid-Atlantic, or the Great Lakes region. Located just off Interstate 81 in Upstate New York, Pulaski is a manageable drive from many major cities: roughly 5 hours from Boston, 5.5 from New York City, 7 from Portland, Maine, and about 6 from Philadelphia or Cleveland. On our recent trip, we made the 7-hour drive from Portland, leaving around midday and arriving in time to check into the Double Eagle Lodge and grab dinner at LD’s, a casual tavern in town. Aside from some rain near Boston, it was a smooth drive with light mid-week traffic.
For those coming from farther afield, flying into Syracuse Hancock International Airport (45 minutes), Albany (2.5 hours), Buffalo (2.5 hours), or Rochester (2 hours) and renting a car is a convenient option. Syracuse is the most efficient hub, offering direct access to I-81 North, which leads straight into Pulaski. Once in town, NY Route 13 serves as the main road running along the river, making it easy to reach Altmar, Pineville, and most of the major fishing access points.
Pulaski’s accessibility is one of the reasons the Salmon River sees consistent angling pressure, especially during the peak of the King Salmon run in September and October. We prefer to make our annual pilgrimage in November, when the steelhead are fresh, the weather is often more cooperative, and the crowds are far lighter. That said, snow and ice can arrive early in this part of New York, so it is important to be prepared for winter road conditions during steelhead season. Reliable transportation and a flexible schedule go a long way when planning a successful trip.
The Fishing
Steelhead fishing on the Salmon River is as diverse as it is exciting. Anglers can choose the approach that fits their preferred style, and in many cases, it makes sense to switch techniques throughout the day. Swinging flies with a spey or switch rod is a classic method here, and we always pack a two-hander with the hope of moving a steelhead on a swung fly. It is an enjoyable, rhythmic style of fishing that allows you to cover water efficiently and settle into a steady cadence of cast, swing, and step. Intruder-style patterns and leeches in a range of colors can all work. Early in the season, bright chartreuse, pink, or orange can stand out well, while black, blue, or purple are reliable choices when the water is colder or clearer.
Nymphing, however, remains the most common and productive method for most fly anglers on the Salmon River. Indicator nymphing, tightline techniques, and euro-style mono rigs all see regular use. Egg patterns, stonefly nymphs, and various attractor nymphs are staples throughout the steelhead season. In November, when fresh fish are pushing in and salmon eggs are abundant in the system, steelhead are often focused heavily on eggs. Finding the right size and shade of egg is often more important than switching entire patterns. Some days it is a matter of changing from an orange egg to a peach one, or adjusting weight and depth until the drift looks right.
On this trip, we chose to employ both swinging and nymphing tactics, and both produced eats. Most of our fishing time was spent nymphing because the egg bite was consistent. Still, after staring at an indicator for several hours, it felt refreshing to pull out the spey rod and cover a piece of water more slowly. Bringing both setups allows you to fish different types of holding water effectively and keeps the day interesting. The rhythm of switching between the two approaches is part of what makes steelheading here so enjoyable.
Day 1: Floating Altmar to Pineville
On Tuesday morning, we grabbed breakfast at Artie’s Hometown Diner before meeting our guide, Rick Smith, at the Pineville boat ramp. Rick has guided us before, so the morning started more like catching up with a friend than gearing up for a serious day of fishing. We sipped coffee in the cool morning air, talked about how the river had been fishing, and loaded our gear into the back of his truck. From Pineville, we made the short drive upstream to the Altmar put-in. This is the most popular stretch to float, and it usually sees a rush of drift boats launching before first light. We prefer a slower start to the day. The steelhead are in the system, and there is no need to race anyone to the river. We pushed off well after the sunrise crowd had dispersed, and that set the tone for the day.
We began the morning nymphing a few classic early-season runs, each one with the right mix of depth, speed, and holding structure. The first couple of hours passed without a grab. The water looked good and the drifts were clean, but sometimes steelhead simply are not where you expect them to be. By late morning, we slid into a narrow piece of water that had the kind of green tint and broken surface that makes you sit up a little straighter. We dropped anchor and settled in. Within a few minutes, Riley was tight to a steelhead. A chrome-bright hen erupted from the water just upstream of the boat, sending spray into the sunlight. It was one of those fish that lets you know instantly you are in for something special. Riley stayed patient and let the fish dictate the pace. Rick handled the net with the kind of ease that comes only from years of guiding. We admired the fish quickly and let her slide back into the current. It was a beautiful moment, and the day felt successful in that instant.
We stayed in that run for a while and hooked several more fish, including another bright hen that ate a peach estaz egg pattern right off a shallow shelf. That fish ran down in front of the boat and tangled my line with Riley’s rig, but Rick worked calmly through the chaos. In just a minute, everything was clear, and the fish was still on. I landed her after a few strong runs, another bright piece of silver against the November water. These are the moments that bring us back to the Salmon River year after year. Nothing about steelheading is guaranteed, and that makes each fish feel earned.
The afternoon slowed as we floated downstream. We fished several runs where we have found fish in past seasons, but the river felt quieter. Steelhead are not hard to catch; they are hard to find, and sometimes the fish are simply somewhere else. Rick worked hard, changing flies, adjusting weight and leader length, and positioning the boat to give us every advantage. Even without more fish, we enjoyed the afternoon. The crowds were gone by then, and we had long stretches of river entirely to ourselves. The light had that late-fall softness, and the sound of the current filled the space where conversation faded. People often say the Salmon River is too crowded, and at times they are right, but there are always moments of peace here if you are willing to look for them.
When we pulled the boat out at Pineville, we were tired and happy. We drove back to town, grabbed dinner, and called it an early night. The first day had already delivered what we came for.
Day 2: The DSR
On Wednesday morning, we made the short drive to the Douglaston Salmon Run, often called the DSR. This private stretch of water sits just upstream of Lake Ontario and is one of the first places fresh steelhead show themselves when they enter the river. Day passes are required, and in our experience, the cost is well worth the access. The water is beautiful, the crowds are lighter than the public sections, and there is always the possibility of finding a fish that still carries the chrome and sea-shimmer of the lake.
We checked in, geared up, and started the day by hiking to a run we have had success in before. The river was running at approximately 800 cfs, high enough to give the fish room to move but still manageable for wading. The air felt damp and cool. The clouds were heavy, but the kind that hold quiet instead of urgency. It was the kind of morning where you take your time tying on your first fly and breathe a little deeper because you know the day could be something special.
Riley stepped into the head of the run and started nymphing through the soft edge water. On his third cast, the indicator paused for just a moment, and he lifted. The fish immediately cartwheeled, bright and silver, and tore downstream. It was the exact kind of fish that brings us back here year after year. I followed with the spey rod and a black and purple intruder, working the swing through the heart of the run, but the fish in that moment wanted eggs, not swung flies. A pair of spey anglers arrived, and we talked for a bit before giving them the water. The DSR has a good rhythm of sharing and rotating runs, and it felt right to move on.
Our next target was a faster piece of water across the river with a deep slot that had held fish in seasons past. Crossing at 800 cfs took patience and caution. Any higher and it would not have been an option. Once we made it across, we spread out and started working the slot. Within minutes I was tight to a steelhead. The fish surged downstream toward the lake, and I was into the backing almost instantly. My 10’ 10” 6wt had enough power to turn him, and slowly the fish came back up into the heart of the run. When Riley slipped the net under him, we both just looked at each other and smiled. It was a heavy buck, thick through the shoulders and full of lake color. A quick photo, and we watched him slide away.
As the wind picked up and rain began to fall, the fishing turned into something memorable. The steelhead were fired up, and the egg bite stayed consistent. Riley went on a run, landing fish one after another, and I spent much of the afternoon laughing, net in hand, watching the whole thing unfold. Some days, you are the one doing the catching. Some days, you are the one doing the cheering. Both feel good when the company is right.
We fished until we were soaked and tired in the best possible way. Eventually, we began the hike back to the truck, rods dripping, boots heavy, and the river moving quietly behind us. The drive home to Maine that afternoon felt easy. The windshield wipers kept time, the conversation drifted in and out, and there was nothing to prove. We had good fish, good weather for the season, and time on the river that felt honest and unhurried.
Trips like this never feel quite long enough, but this one gave us more than enough to carry into winter.
Local Guides
Hiring a local guide can be a valuable way to shorten the learning curve on the Salmon River. The system is large, and conditions change quickly; experienced guides can help you understand where fish are holding and why. On this trip, we fished with Rick Smith of Rick’s Guide Service (315) 532-5937. Rick has guided on the river for many years and knows how to read its nuances, from subtle depth changes to seasonal migration patterns. His relaxed style and thoughtful instruction always make for an enjoyable day on the water.
Another well-regarded guide in the area is Nate Adam of Up n Adam Guide Service (315) 256-3283. Nate is a seasoned angler who spends significant time on both the public stretches and the Douglaston Salmon Run. He offers walk-wade trips as well as drift boat outings, and is known for his patient teaching style.
There are many other excellent local guides as well, including those listed on the Douglaston Salmon Run website. If you are new to steelhead fishing on the Salmon River or want to make the most of a limited fishing window, booking a guide for at least one day is highly recommended.
Local Lodging and Dining
Pulaski and the surrounding towns offer a range of lodging options that cater well to anglers. On this trip we stayed at the Double Eagle Lodge, which provided clean, comfortable rooms and an easy drive to all major access points. For anglers looking for a more full-service experience, Tailwater Lodge in Altmar is the most established fishing lodge in the area. Tailwater has well-appointed rooms, on-site dining, a bar, and a relaxed lodge atmosphere that makes it a popular choice during steelhead season. Smaller motels and angler-focused lodges are also common throughout Pulaski and Altmar, including Whitaker’s (with an attached fly shop) and Fox Hollow Lodge, which offers cabins and lodge rooms close to the river. During peak salmon season, these places fill quickly, but in November and later into the winter, there are usually rooms available with less advance planning.
Dining in Pulaski leans toward simple, hearty meals that hit the spot after a day on the water. LD’s on the River is a great choice for a burger and a beer, especially when you want something casual and close to town. Stefano’s serves pizza and Italian fare and is a reliable option for takeout or a relaxed sit-down meal. The Altmar Hotel offers home-style cooking with generous portions, ideal when you need to warm up and refuel. Breakfast is easy at Artie’s Home Town Diner, which has long been a morning gathering spot for anglers. If you want to catch up on river talk at the end of the day, 11 North Bar & Grill is a popular stop for local guides.
There are also quick-service and familiar chain options along Route 11 and in town, including Dunkin, McDonald’s, Arby’s, and Burger King, which come in handy for early starts or late returns. Whether you prefer a classic fishing lodge experience, a no-frills motel close to the river, or simply a warm diner meal before first light, Pulaski has what you need to settle in and focus on the fishing.
Equipment
Swing Rod:
Sage Spey R8 11' 6" 7wt
Sage Spey II Fly Reel
Rio Elite Skagit Max Power Shooting Head - 475gr
Indicator Nymphing Rod:
Hardy Marksman 10' 8wt
Hardy Averon 7000 Fly Reel
SA Amplitude Anadro Fly Line
Euro Nymphing Rod:
Thomas & Thomas Contact 2 10' 8" 6wt
Hardy Averon 7000 Fly Reel
Rio FIPS Euro Nymph Line
Conclusion
This trip reminded us why we return to the Salmon River each fall. The fishing had its fast moments and its quiet stretches, which is exactly what steelheading should be. We caught bright, powerful fish, learned a few more subtleties of the river, and enjoyed time on the water without hurry. The combination of accessible travel, varied water, and the chance at truly memorable fish makes Pulaski a place worth visiting year after year. As always, the river offered just enough mystery to keep us thinking about it long after the drive home.
If you’d like to learn more about fishing the Salmon River, give us a call at 888-413-5211 or drop us a line at [email protected].
Comments
(0)No comments yet. Be the first!